Waneta Lake Homes for Sale
Tucked between Seneca and Keuka Lakes, Waneta Lake offers a peaceful, private lakefront experience with all the natural beauty the Finger Lakes are known for, but without the crowds. Waneta Lake real estate appeals to buyers looking for seasonal cottages, family getaways, and quiet retreats with direct lake access.
Whether you’re an avid angler, a weekend kayaker, or simply want a cozy lakeside view, Waneta Lake offers charming homes in a relaxed setting.
2 listings
$597,000
$575,000
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data
Exchange (IDX) Program of the Genesee Region Real Estate Information Service (GENRIS). Real estate listings held by firms are marked with the Powered by Homesteadnet.com/REALTOR®
logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker's Firm Name).
Real Estate Snapshot: Waneta Lake
Waneta Lake is smaller than the major Finger Lakes, but that makes it all the more desirable for those seeking a low-key, peaceful environment.
- Single-family homes
- Seasonal cottages
- Waterfront estates
- Lake lots and land for sale
Waneta Lake is ideal for buyers who want the Finger Lakes experience, without the Finger Lakes traffic.
About Waneta Lake
Waneta Lake is a 780-acre glacial lake located just west of Tyrone, NY, and sits adjacent to its sister lake, Lamoka. Although not technically part of the eleven “official” Finger Lakes, it shares the same glacial origin and picturesque setting.
Lake Facts:
- Surface Area: 780 acres
- Length: Approx. 2.9 miles
- Max Depth: ~29 feet
- Connected To: Lamoka Lake via canal
- Known For: Tranquility, fishing, kayaking, seasonal living
Fishing on Waneta Lake
Fishing is a major draw for Waneta Lake residents and visitors. The lake is regularly stocked and has excellent populations of both game and panfish.
Common Fish Species:
- Muskellunge (Musky)
- Largemouth Bass
- Chain Pickerel
- Crappie
- Bluegill
- Yellow Perch
- Pumpkinseed
Lifestyle & Recreation
Waneta Lake offers year-round relaxation and recreation:
- Boating, kayaking, canoeing
- Paddleboarding and swimming
- Ice fishing and snowmobiling in winter
- Close proximity to the Finger Lakes Wine Trail
- Quiet roads perfect for biking and evening walks
Wake up to lake views, cast a line from your dock, and enjoy the simple beauty of life at Waneta Lake.
Local Attractions
While Waneta Lake itself is quiet and residential, it sits near some of the most popular Finger Lakes destinations:
- Wine Country: Just 15–30 minutes from wineries on Keuka and Seneca Lakes
- Hiking: Sugar Hill State Forest and Finger Lakes Trail nearby
- Shopping & Dining: Penn Yan, Hammondsport, and Watkins Glen are within a short drive
- Events: Finger Lakes Wine Festival, antique boat shows, summer lake events
Services & Nearby Amenities
- Hospitals:
- Ira Davenport Memorial Hospital (Bath)
- Schuyler Hospital (Watkins Glen)
- Airports:
- Elmira-Corning Regional Airport
- Penn Yan-Yates County Airport
- Marinas & Boat Launches:
- Public launch on east side of Waneta Lake
- Nearby access to Lamoka Lake as well
School Districts
Depending on location, Waneta Lake homes may fall into one of several local school districts:
- Hammondsport Central School District
- Bradford Central School District
- Dundee Central School District
Nearby Communities
Tyrone
This small hamlet sits between Waneta and Lamoka Lakes. Residents enjoy peaceful lake views, access to both lakes, and a rural lifestyle perfect for relaxation or retirement.
Hammondsport
Located just 20 minutes to the northwest, Hammondsport is known for its historic charm, wine legacy, and vibrant lakefront community on Keuka Lake.
Wayne
A quiet, rural area to the north of the lake with larger lots and wooded properties. Wayne is ideal for buyers looking for privacy near both Waneta and Keuka Lakes.
Watkins Glen
Roughly 30 minutes to the east, Watkins Glen offers a bustling village scene, a famous state park, and access to Seneca Lake’s southern tip.
Work With a Local Real Estate Expert
Ready to buy or sell on Waneta Lake? Get personalized guidance from a Finger Lakes real estate professional who understands seasonal markets, waterfront regulations, and the local lifestyle.
Contact us for current listings, property tours, or a free market analysis of your Waneta Lake home.