Torrey NY Homes for Sale
Set between the eastern edge of Keuka Lake and the western shore of Seneca Lake, Torrey, NY is a peaceful and scenic town at the heart of Finger Lakes wine country. Known for its open farmland, lakeside properties, and easygoing pace, Torrey offers an incredible opportunity for buyers looking to settle into a quieter lifestyle with access to both lakefront living and regional attractions.
Whether you’re searching for a lake cottage, a short-term rental property, or wide-open acreage, real estate in Torrey provides value, privacy, and timeless Finger Lakes character.
Sorry, your search returned no selections.
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data
Exchange (IDX) Program of the Genesee Region Real Estate Information Service (GENRIS). Real estate listings held by firms are marked with the Powered by Homesteadnet.com/REALTOR®
logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker's Firm Name).
Explore Real Estate in Torrey, NY
Homes for sale in Torrey reflect the town’s natural beauty and rural charm. You’ll find a mix of waterfront cottages, country homes, and land parcels ideal for homesteading, new builds, or vineyards.
Available property types include:
- Lakefront homes along the east branch of Keuka Lake
- Seasonal cottages and vacation rentals
- Farmhouses and updated country homes with acreage
- Undeveloped land for custom builds or agricultural use
Torrey’s real estate market offers lower density and more space, especially compared to nearby Penn Yan or Geneva—making it a great option for buyers seeking peace, views, and versatility.
Outdoor Recreation & Lake Access
Living in Torrey means you’re surrounded by nature, with Keuka Lake to the west and Seneca Lake to the east. The area offers endless opportunities to enjoy life outdoors—whether you’re boating, biking, or walking through the vineyards.
Outdoor highlights include:
- Fishing, boating, and paddling on both lakes
- Hiking and birdwatching in nearby wildlife areas
- Easy access to the Keuka Outlet Trail, which runs through the town and connects Keuka and Seneca Lakes
- Winter activities like snowshoeing and cross-country skiing
With far less traffic and tourism than other lake towns, Torrey gives residents room to enjoy the outdoors at their own pace.
Wineries, Dining & Nearby Attractions
Torrey is part of both the Keuka Lake Wine Trail and the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, placing you in the heart of the region’s wine scene.
Nearby vineyards include:
- Fox Run Vineyards – known for wine, food, and lake views
- Anthony Road Wine Company – casual tastings and events
- Prejean Winery – just minutes away on the Seneca side
- Keuka Spring and Hunt Country Vineyards – easily accessible from the Keuka side
Dining options, farm markets, and small shops are available in nearby Penn Yan, Geneva, and Dresden, all within a short drive.
Schools & Community Life
Torrey is served by the Penn Yan Central School District, which provides a full K–12 education with strong academics, extracurriculars, and community engagement.
Additional local benefits include:
- Proximity to Keuka College for cultural events and continuing education
- Easy access to community events, festivals, and seasonal markets in Penn Yan and Geneva
- A close-knit, rural atmosphere where neighbors still know one another
History & Landscape
Founded in the early 1800s, Torrey has deep agricultural roots that still shape the landscape today. The town’s farms, vineyards, and old homesteads offer a glimpse into the region’s past—while new homes and lakefront developments add modern comfort to this timeless setting.
From stone barns to scenic back roads, Torrey offers a quiet, enduring connection to the land.
Why Buyers Are Choosing Torrey, NY
- Lake access and lake views without high traffic
- Centrally located between Keuka and Seneca Lakes
- Strong potential for seasonal rental income
- Affordable land and larger lot sizes
- Close to wineries, hiking trails, and scenic byways
- Peaceful Finger Lakes lifestyle near top destinations
Start Your Search with The Mark Malcolm Team
If you’re ready to explore homes for sale in Torrey, NY, The Mark Malcolm Team is here to help. Whether you’re looking for a waterfront cottage, a rural estate, or undeveloped land to build your dream home, we’ll guide you through every step with expert insight and personal service.
Contact us today and take the first step toward owning property in Torrey.