Pulteney NY Homes for Sale

Explore Real Estate in Pulteney, NY

Real estate in Pulteney showcases the region’s diverse landscapes and low-density living. Buyers can find everything from affordable lake-access cottages and vacation rentals to custom-built homes with panoramic views of Keuka Lake and the surrounding hills.

Common property types include:

• Waterfront homes with docks and decks
• Hilltop houses with vineyard views
• Seasonal cabins and short-term rental options
• Rural homesites with acreage for gardening or small-scale farming

Many properties in Pulteney are tucked into wooded lots or perched along bluff roads, providing breathtaking sunrises and a sense of seclusion that’s hard to find in more developed lake towns.

Outdoor Recreation & Nearby Attractions

Pulteney offers quick access to everything that makes the Finger Lakes region special—especially for those who love the outdoors, the water, and the wine trail.

Local outdoor highlights include:

• Keuka Lake boating, kayaking, and swimming
• Hiking and wildlife watching in the nearby Urbana State Forest
• Scenic cycling and driving routes along County Route 76
• Fishing in the lake’s crystal-clear waters
• Stargazing from bluff-top properties far from city lights

Just a short drive south brings you to Hammondsport, home to restaurants, shops, and events. Wineries dot the nearby hills, making tasting and touring part of the everyday lifestyle.

Local Wineries, Farm Markets & Experiences

Pulteney is surrounded by the roots of New York’s wine country. Local wineries like Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars—just minutes away—are nationally renowned, while others like Bully Hill and Heron Hill offer casual tastings, food pairings, and stunning views.

Other nearby attractions include:

• The Glenn H. Curtiss Museum – a nod to the region’s aviation legacy
• The Windmill Farm & Craft Market – a regional favorite for local goods
• Live music events at nearby vineyards and lakefront venues
• Seasonal farmers markets and u-pick farms throughout Steuben County

Though Pulteney itself is primarily residential and agricultural, its location makes it easy to enjoy the best of the lake without the crowds.

Schools & Community

Families living in Pulteney are served by the Hammondsport Central School District, a small but close-knit district known for its focus on student support, small class sizes, and community involvement.

Additional educational resources and activities can be found through:

• The Hammondsport Public Library
• Youth sports and seasonal events in Hammondsport and surrounding towns
• Proximity to Keuka College, which offers continuing education and community enrichment opportunities

A Legacy of Wine, Land, and Lakeside Living

Founded in 1808, the Town of Pulteney carries a deep connection to the early settlement of the Keuka Lake region. Once part of the expansive Pulteney Estate, the area has long supported agriculture and viticulture, which still shape the landscape today.

Old stone barns, hillside vineyards, and farmhouses passed down through generations preserve a sense of place here—and many modern homes are designed to blend naturally into that setting.

Why Buyers Are Choosing Pulteney, NY

• Bluff-top views and peaceful lakefront living
• Lower property density and more privacy
• Ideal for short-term rentals or seasonal homes
• Close to Hammondsport, wineries, and Keuka Lake access
• Room to garden, hike, and enjoy the outdoors
• Affordable options compared to larger lake towns

Start Your Search with The Mark Malcolm Team

When you’re ready to explore homes for sale in Pulteney, NY, The Mark Malcolm Team is here to help. With decades of experience throughout the Finger Lakes region, we’ll guide you through the local market with honesty, insight, and the personalized service you deserve.

Whether you’re dreaming of a bluff-top retreat, a lakefront cottage, or a home with space to roam, we’re ready to help you find the right property in Pulteney.

Contact us today to begin your search.