Milo NY Homes for Sale

Explore Real Estate in Milo, NY

Milo offers an appealing mix of residential neighborhoods, agricultural land, and lakefront property—often at lower prices and with more privacy than homes located directly in Penn Yan or Hammondsport.

Available properties include:

• Lakeview and lakefront homes on the eastern shore of Keuka Lake
• Renovated farmhouses on multi-acre parcels
• Quiet residential homes close to Penn Yan village amenities
• Seasonal rental-friendly cottages and cabins

With larger lot sizes, mature trees, and peaceful roads, many homes in Milo feel like private retreats—whether you’re living here full-time or visiting seasonally.

Outdoor Recreation & Keuka Lake Access

Milo’s location offers easy access to both arms of Keuka Lake, making it ideal for those who love life on the water. Whether you’re launching a kayak or relaxing on your deck with lake views, the outdoors is always just outside your door.

Local outdoor highlights include:

• Fishing, boating, and paddleboarding on Keuka Lake
• Keuka Outlet Trail – a scenic biking and walking trail connecting Penn Yan to Dresden, running through the town
• Nearby parks like Indian Pines and Red Jacket
• Cross-country skiing and snowshoeing in the winter months
• Scenic drives through Mennonite farmlands and fall foliage routes

Local Wineries, Dining & Everyday Convenience

Milo borders some of the region’s most acclaimed vineyards, including those on the Keuka Wine Trail. Just minutes from your door, you’ll find:

• Keuka Spring Vineyards – award-winning wines with lake views
• Domaine LeSeurre Winery – French-inspired with exceptional hospitality
• Barrington Cellars – a quiet gem off the beaten path

While Milo itself is primarily rural, Penn Yan is just minutes away, offering:

• Grocery stores and essentials
• Local shops, restaurants, and farmer’s markets
• Coffee shops, wine bars, and casual dining

This gives residents the convenience of town living without sacrificing privacy or space.

Schools & Community Life

Milo is part of the Penn Yan Central School District, which includes:

• Penn Yan Elementary School
• Penn Yan Middle School
• Penn Yan Academy (high school)

The area benefits from a strong sense of community, supported by local events, seasonal festivals, and a connection to both Penn Yan village and the wider Yates County region.

Agriculture, History & Rural Character

Settled in the late 1700s and incorporated in 1818, Milo is one of the oldest towns in Yates County. It retains its agricultural character and Mennonite heritage, visible in the farms, fields, and horse-drawn buggies that still frequent local roads.

Milo’s rural charm is a key part of its appeal: stone barns, historic homes, and generational farms dot the landscape, preserving a sense of tradition in a modern world.

Why Buyers Are Choosing Milo, NY

• Lakefront and rural homes at lower density
• Easy access to Penn Yan and Keuka Lake
• Ideal for full-time living or seasonal getaways
• Strong short-term rental potential
• Scenic trails, historic charm, and peaceful surroundings

Start Your Search with The Mark Malcolm Team

When you’re ready to explore real estate in Milo, NY, The Mark Malcolm Team brings decades of local experience and market insight to help you make the right move. From lakefront properties to secluded country homes, Mark will help you find the perfect fit—backed by honest advice and deep regional knowledge.

Reach out today to start your home search in Milo.