Keuka Lake Homes for Sale

About Keuka Lake

Known historically as “Crooked Lake,” Keuka is the third-largest Finger Lake and the only one shaped like a ‘Y’. It was formed by glacial activity thousands of years ago and is fed by both the upland hills and natural springs.

Lake Facts:

• Length: 19.6 miles
• Area: 11,584 acres
• Shoreline: 59 miles
• Max Depth: 183 feet
• Thermocline: 30–35 feet
• Counties: Yates County, Steuben County
• Notable Villages: Penn Yan (northeast tip), Hammondsport (south tip), Branchport (northwest arm)
• Known For: Bidirectional flow (north and south), scenic vineyards, historic towns

Recreation & Lifestyle

Living on Keuka Lake means you’re never far from the water, or the next adventure.

Water Activities:

• Boating, kayaking, sailing, paddleboarding
• Swimming in crystal-clear water
• Waterskiing and jet skiing
• Public boat ramps throughout the lake
• Ice fishing and snowshoeing in winter

Outdoor Fun:

• Sugar Hill State Forest (camping, hiking, horseback riding, fire tower views)
• Keuka Lake State Park
•  A number of Local marinas:

Fishing on Keuka Lake

Keuka Lake is a beloved destination for anglers, known for its clear water and abundant fish populations. Whether you’re casting off from your private dock or joining a local fishing charter, there’s something here for every skill level.

Common Fish Species:

• Lake Trout
• Brown Trout
• Rainbow Trout
• Atlantic Salmon
• Smallmouth Bass
• Northern Pike
• Yellow Perch
• Rock Bass
• Bluegill
• Black Crappie
• Pumpkinseed
• Smelt

Wine, Food & Local Attractions

Keuka Lake is at the heart of New York’s wine country and is home to more than 20 wineries and tasting rooms, including:

• Weis Winery
• Keuka Springs
• Hunt Vineyards
• Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery
• Heron Hill Winery
• Bully Hill Vineyards
• Pleasant Valley Wine Company

You’ll also find charming restaurants, boutique shops, museums, and year-round events in Penn Yan, Branchport, and Hammondsport. Seasonal festivals and farmer’s markets give residents a true taste of Finger Lakes living.

Services & Amenities

Keuka Lake offers both seclusion and convenience:

• Hospitals Nearby:
  • Soldiers & Sailors Memorial Hospital (Penn Yan)
  • Ira Davenport Memorial Hospital (Bath)
• Airports:
  • Penn Yan–Yates County Airport
  • Elmira–Corning Regional Airport

Schools & Education

Families who choose Keuka Lake as their full-time home will find several quality school districts nearby:

• Penn Yan Central School District
• Hammondsport Central School District
• Dundee Central School District
• Private and faith-based schools within driving distance

Nearby Communities

Penn Yan

Located at the northeastern tip of Keuka Lake, Penn Yan serves as a cultural and economic hub of the region. It offers historic charm, a walkable downtown with shops and cafes, and quick access to marinas and public parks.

Branchport

Tucked into the northwestern arm of the lake, Branchport offers tranquil waterfront properties and easy access to Keuka Lake State Park. It’s ideal for buyers looking for a quieter setting with rich natural surroundings.

Hammondsport

At the southern end of Keuka Lake, Hammondsport is known for its wine heritage and vibrant community feel. Home to several historic wineries and the Glenn H. Curtiss Museum, it’s a favorite for both full-time residents and vacation homeowners.

Jerusalem

This scenic township stretches along the west side of the lake and features rolling hills, agricultural land, and lakeview homes. It’s popular with buyers seeking privacy and panoramic lake views.

Wayne

Positioned near the southwestern corner of Keuka, Wayne offers spacious lots, wooded parcels, and access to some of the most serene stretches of shoreline. It’s a great choice for those looking to blend outdoor living with peaceful seclusion.

Milo

Surrounding much of Penn Yan, Milo offers a blend of residential neighborhoods, farmland, and lake access. It provides a strong sense of community with convenient access to schools and services.

Barrington

Just east of Branchport, Barrington boasts a mix of vineyards, forests, and lakefront cottages. Its rural charm and slower pace appeal to those seeking a relaxed lifestyle.

Urbana

Urbana is home to Hammondsport and several lakeside communities. Residents enjoy walkability, festivals, and easy access to the southern lake marinas and amenities.

Pulteney

This hillside community offers stunning western views of Keuka Lake. It’s known for larger acreage properties, vineyards, and a quiet, rural atmosphere.

Work with a Local Expert

With more than three decades of experience and deep roots in the Finger Lakes, Mark Malcolm and his Team knows Keuka Lake inside and out. Whether you’re buying your first cottage, upgrading to a larger home, or looking for the perfect investment property, Mark provides unmatched insight and support.

Contact us today to schedule a tour, request more information, or get a free valuation of your current property.