Jerusalem NY Homes For Sale

Explore Real Estate in Jerusalem, NY

From charming cottages nestled in the hills to spacious lakefront estates with private docks, real estate in Jerusalem reflects the area’s tranquil lifestyle and natural beauty. Many properties feature larger lot sizes, ideal for gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying the wide-open views. Lakefront homes offer direct access to boating, swimming, and fishing on Keuka Lake, a major draw for seasonal visitors and year-round residents alike.

Buyers will also find options suited for short-term rentals and vacation use, making Jerusalem a compelling choice for those looking to invest in the Finger Lakes market.

Things to Do in Jerusalem & Around Keuka Lake

Living in Jerusalem gives you access to some of the region’s most iconic experiences. You’re just minutes from Hunt Country Vineyards, one of the oldest farm wineries in New York, as well as Keuka Spring Vineyards, Stever Hill Vineyards, and Domaine LeSeurre, all offering award-winning wine and stunning views.

Outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy:

• Boating, kayaking, or paddleboarding on Keuka Lake
• Hiking scenic trails through Italy Hill or Keuka Lake State Park
• Cycling the Keuka Lake Wine Trail
• Fishing in the lake’s deep, cool waters

Whether you’re hosting family for a weekend getaway or enjoying a solo morning paddle, this is a community that invites you to slow down and stay awhile.

Local Shops, Dining & Community Events

While Jerusalem itself is primarily residential and agricultural, nearby Branchport and Penn Yan offer plenty of local flavor. Visit the Branchport Hardware & General Store, Keuka Restaurant, or enjoy a Friday night fish fry at a local tavern.

Seasonal farmers markets, live music, and wine-and-food events dot the calendar throughout Yates County, especially during the summer and harvest seasons. And with the Keuka Lake Association, local libraries, and community centers nearby, residents can feel connected without the crowds.

Schools Serving Jerusalem, NY

Families in Jerusalem are served by the Penn Yan Central School District, which offers K–12 education with a strong reputation in the region. The district includes Penn Yan Elementary, Middle, and Academy High School, which offers AP courses, athletics, and extracurricular programs.

For those seeking private or specialty education, nearby options include Keuka College, a small liberal arts school just south of Jerusalem in the Village of Keuka Park, offering a vibrant campus and enriching cultural events for the community.

A Town Steeped in Finger Lakes History

The town of Jerusalem was established in 1789 and played a key role in the early settlement of western New York. With a deep agricultural history and longstanding ties to the wine industry, Jerusalem has maintained its small-town authenticity while quietly evolving into a destination for those seeking beauty, privacy, and connection to nature.

Old homesteads, stone barns, and working farms still dot the landscape, providing a sense of continuity and grounding in a rapidly changing world.

Why Buyers Are Choosing Jerusalem, NY

• Lake access without the tourist crowds
• Ideal for second homes or seasonal living
• Larger lots and lower density than nearby villages
• Proximity to award-winning wineries, hiking, and outdoor recreation
  Strong potential for investment or short-term rental use
• Unmatched views of Keuka Lake and the hills beyond

Whether you’re relocating, retiring, or investing, Jerusalem offers peaceful living in one of the Finger Lakes’ most beautiful corners.

Start Your Search with The Mark Malcolm Team

With decades of experience in the Finger Lakes real estate market, The Mark Malcolm Team brings unmatched local knowledge, personal service, and a deep understanding of what makes this area so special. From lakefront showings to investment properties with rental potential, Mark helps buyers navigate every step of the process with confidence.

Ready to find your perfect property in Jerusalem, NY? Contact us today.