Benton NY Homes for Sale

Explore Real Estate in Benton, NY

Benton’s housing market includes everything from historic farmhouses and renovated colonials to vacant land ready for vineyards or new construction. The area is zoned for agricultural use in many areas, making it attractive to hobby farmers, winegrowers, and buyers looking to build in a peaceful rural setting.

Common property types include:

• Farmhouses on multi-acre parcels
• Single-family homes near Penn Yan
• Land for homesteading, vineyards, or recreation
• Rental properties and long-term investments

Many properties in Benton feature generous lot sizes, quiet road frontage, and scenic views of open farmland and wooded areas.

Outdoor Recreation & Scenic Surroundings

Living in Benton means you’re never far from outdoor activities, lake access, and nature. The town sits between Keuka and Seneca Lakes, making it a great jumping-off point for boating, hiking, and vineyard touring.

Outdoor highlights include:

• Fishing, boating, and paddling on nearby Seneca Lake
• Hiking trails in surrounding state forests and Finger Lakes parks
• Country roads perfect for cycling and scenic drives

• Proximity to the Keuka Outlet Trail for walking and biking

Whether you’re exploring the outdoors or relaxing on your own land, Benton offers peace and quiet with big-sky views.

Wineries, Local Attractions & Dining

Benton sits near the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, home to many of New York’s most renowned wineries. The area is ideal for wine lovers, entrepreneurs, or anyone looking to live close to vineyard country.

Nearby attractions include:

• Torrey Ridge Winery, Anthony Road Wine Company, and Fox Run Vineyards

• Seasonal farm markets and u-pick farms throughout Yates County
• Casual dining and shopping in Penn Yan, just a 10-minute drive south

From tasting rooms to local cafes, the Benton area delivers authentic Finger Lakes charm without the crowds.

Schools & Community Life

Benton is served by the Penn Yan Central School District, which includes:

• Penn Yan Elementary School
• Penn Yan Middle School
• Penn Yan Academy (high school)

Families benefit from:

• Strong academic programming
• Extracurricular and athletic options
• A safe, supportive learning environment

The community of Benton is small but active, with seasonal events, agricultural ties, and multi-generational families who call this peaceful town home.

A Place with Deep Agricultural Roots

Founded in the early 1800s, Benton has long been a hub of farming, Mennonite craftsmanship, and generational land stewardship. Today, many original barns, stone homes, and pastures remain, helping preserve the region’s identity as a working rural community.

Benton’s location—just outside Penn Yan and near Seneca Lake—makes it uniquely positioned for both traditional country living and wine tourism development.

Why Buyers Are Choosing Benton, NY

• Affordable land and homes with acreage
• Proximity to Penn Yan, Seneca Lake, and local wineries
• Ideal for homesteading, farming, or new construction
• Strong community and rural values
• Quiet setting with beautiful views and low density

Start Your Search with The Mark Malcolm Team

Ready to explore homes and land for sale in Benton, NY? The Mark Malcolm Team has decades of experience in Yates County and the surrounding Finger Lakes area. Whether you’re buying your first home, seeking a quiet country retreat, or investing in agricultural land, we’re here to help.

Contact us today to begin your search in Benton.