Tyrone NY Homes for Sale

Over 3/4's of a BILLION DOLLARS in closed sales transactions

Fair Housing Notice & Standardized Operating Procedures

Tucked between Lamoka Lake and Waneta Lake in Schuyler County, Tyrone, NY is a peaceful, rural town with beautiful scenery, quiet roads, and easy access to the Finger Lakes region. Known for its rolling farmland, lakefront properties, and outdoor recreation, Tyrone offers a laid-back lifestyle that appeals to year-round residents and seasonal homeowners alike.

Whether you’re looking for a weekend escape near the water or a homestead with acreage, real estate in Tyrone blends natural beauty with affordability. Many homes sit on multi-acre lots, with some boasting private lake frontage, wooded settings, or views of the surrounding hills.

Sorry, your search returned no selections.

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of the Genesee Region Real Estate Information Service (GENRIS). Real estate listings held by firms are marked with the Powered by Homesteadnet.com/REALTOR® logo and detailed information about them includes the Listing Broker's Firm Name).

Waterfront Homes on Lamoka and Waneta Lake

Tyrone is home to both Lamoka Lake and Waneta Lake—two connected Finger Lakes known for boating, fishing, and their relaxed, family-friendly feel. Lakefront homes and cottages are available on both lakes, with a range of options from year-round residences to seasonal getaways.

Lamoka Lake: Known for its calm waters and scenic sunsets, Lamoka offers waterfront homes with docks, decks, and a true lakeside lifestyle.
Waneta Lake: A quieter setting with excellent fishing, Waneta properties tend to have larger lots and a more private feel—ideal for nature lovers.

Acreage, Wooded Lots, and Country Living

If you’re looking for space, Tyrone offers generous parcels of land perfect for building, farming, or simply enjoying peace and privacy. Many properties feature mature trees, open fields, and opportunities for gardening, recreation, or keeping animals.

The area is well-suited for:

Homesteads and hobby farms
Cabins and rustic retreats
Vacant land ready for development

Easy Access to Watkins Glen, Hammondsport & More

While Tyrone feels tucked away, it’s surprisingly convenient. You’re within 20–30 minutes of popular Finger Lakes destinations like:

Watkins Glen: A scenic drive east brings you to Watkins Glen State Park, Seneca Lake wineries, and local restaurants.
Hammondsport: Head west to this charming village on Keuka Lake, known for its shops, wine tasting, and lake activities.

This location makes Tyrone a great home base for exploring the entire region while enjoying a quieter lifestyle at home.

Start Your Search with The Mark Malcolm Team

Ready to explore homes and land for sale in Tyrone, NY? The Mark Malcolm Team has decades of experience in the surrounding Finger Lakes area. Whether you’re buying your first home, seeking a quiet country retreat, or investing in agricultural land, we’re here to help.